The Sales TravelerIndependent · Reader-funded · A partnership buys reach, never a ratingField Index Live
The Sales TravelerThe decision desk for revenue travel
Read the Field Brief
The Index Desk · Promised vs Delivered

Every Index, One Row

By Rachel Julian, Editor-in-Chief · · 4 min read

What 181 suppliers promise, how much of it is backed by a source we publish, and whether anyone can measure what they actually deliver.

Direct answer: Across 14 indexes this desk scores 181 suppliers on published commitments. 54 of those carry a source URL in the published data. On the delivered side, 1 index can be measured against an independent record, 13 were searched and have no public source, 0 is not applicable and 0 are unsearched.

14 indexes score what a supplier publishes as a commitment. This page adds the two columns that matter next: how much of that promise is backed by a source URL this desk publishes, and whether the supplier's actual delivery can be measured at all. 1 can. 13 were searched and cannot. That second number is the finding.

IndexVendors scoredPublish a sourceDelivered side
The Deal-Day Airline Index
dataset
100 of 10 0%Measured the measurement
The Sales-Ready Index
dataset
5017 of 50 34%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Executive Tier
dataset
153 of 15 20%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Layover Office Index
dataset
150 of 15 0%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Booking Channel Index
dataset
102 of 10 20%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Conference ROI Index
dataset
100 of 10 0%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Expense Velocity Index
dataset
100 of 10 0%Searched · no public source 4 sources checked
The Road Office Index
dataset
100 of 10 0%Searched · no public source 2 sources checked
The Roaming Index
dataset
1010 of 10 100%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Road-Ready Sales AI Index
dataset
100 of 10 0%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Status Yield Index
dataset
90 of 9 0%Searched · no public source 4 sources checked
The Apartment-Stay Index
dataset
88 of 8 100%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked
The Curb-to-Client Index
dataset
88 of 8 100%Searched · no public source 4 sources checked
The Corporate Travel Management Index
dataset
66 of 6 100%Searched · no public source 6 sources checked

Where the answer is yes, the measurement gets its own desk. Airlines are the one category with a federal reporting duty behind them, and the airline scorecards carry the delivered side in full: on-time and cancellation rates per carrier, and the split showing whether the airline was the reason.

Derived from /data/screener.json, which is generated from the catalogue, the delivered-side rulings and the verification statements. Every figure above reconciles against those files, and the build fails if it does not. 54 of 181 scored vendors publish at least one source URL.

Why "cannot be measured" is the useful column

A ranking can be reproduced by anyone overnight. A ruling that a category cannot be measured cannot, because it requires having done the searching and being willing to publish the result. Each of the 13 rows marked searched · no public source carries the number of sources checked before that ruling was made, and its record names them and states what would change it.

The distinction the desk refuses to blur: searched and unmeasurable is a finding; nobody has searched is the absence of one. Both are published under their own name, and there are currently 0 of the second.

How to read a row

Vendors scored is how many suppliers the index rules on. Publish a source is how many of those have a source URL in the published data, where it reads 0, the scores were ruled by a named editor against documents that were read but not captured, and the verification statement for that index says so rather than implying paper exists. Delivered side is the human ruling about whether a third party could measure the same suppliers on what they actually deliver.

On the road for work a lot?

The Field Brief: sharp travel-ROI notes for the people who carry the quarter through airports. No signup, no email, nothing to unsubscribe from: read it free in the open archive.

Read the brief →
Derived from /data/screener.json — the catalogue, the delivered-side rulings and the verification statements. A partnership buys reach, never a rating.
The Field Brief · Free · Weekly

Don't just read the discipline.
Run it.

One framework, one benchmark, one field note from the road, every week, written for the people who carry the quarter through airports. No signup, no email, nothing to unsubscribe from.

Read the brief →

Free, in the open archive: no signup · read it at /business-travel-news/